Same Team Partners

HR & People · 11 tools ranked

Best Performance Management Software for Marketing and Creative Agencies in 2026

Small Improvements ranks first in performance management software for marketing and creative agencies, followed by Workleap and Treams. Performance management software for marketing and creative agencies supports quick feedback, project-linked goals and recognition for small, fast-moving teams with little HR staff.

The top three

How this list is ordered: by our editorial assessment of fit for organizations of 50 to 1,000 people. Vendors can pay for more visibility; how that works is explained in our disclosure, linked above every ranking. No commission is earned on clicks or purchases, and we do not work as an affiliate.

What is performance management software for marketing and creative agencies?

Performance management software for marketing and creative agencies is a system for feedback, goals, 1:1s and reviews that fits project-based teams: it collects input after a campaign or pitch, keeps development goals alive between projects, and gives account leads and creative directors a simple way to talk with their people. It does not manage timesheets or briefs. It supports retention by making recognition and growth visible.

How we ranked these

An agency sells the judgment of its people, and the people know it. Designers, strategists and account managers move from one pitch to the next, and the work that earns praise is often finished at midnight before a client presentation.

Waiting for an annual review to say so is too late. Turnover makes the problem sharper.

Agency staff leave for the next studio, the next client or freelance work, and a manager who learns about a grievance in an exit interview has lost the person already. Meanwhile the HR function is one person, or an office manager with HR on the side.

The software has to work for that person first, and for the managers second. We looked for tools that suit that rhythm: quick peer and creative feedback, light goals tied to projects, praise that people actually see, and a price a small team can carry.

We read vendor pages for marketing and agency language, for recognition features and for the setup effort each product asks of a tiny HR team.

Setup: can one office manager launch it in a week

A small agency has no project team for HR software, so the tool must launch with a template and a short list of questions. Look at what the vendor ships on day one: a review template, a 1:1 agenda, a feedback request. Small Improvements and PerformYard describe quick launches from included templates, and Primalogik includes onboarding at no fee. Test the first month honestly.

Who will remind the creative director to hold the 1:1? A tool that nudges managers in the chat app, as Weekdone, Bonusly and Workleap do through Slack or Teams, saves the office manager from becoming the police.

The real price: per seat, minimums and the freelancer problem

Agencies run on a core team plus freelancers, so a seat price hides a headcount question. Small Improvements lists $3, $6 and $9 per user per month with a 20-user minimum. Kenjo shows €6 and €10 tiers, Perdoo has a free plan and a Premium tier from €6.40, and Bonusly starts at $3. Workleap publishes yearly plans from $4,999 plus $32 per manager a month, and Primalogik asks for a quote.

Decide in advance whether freelancers get a seat. A tool that charges for every person who ever receives praise gets expensive in a studio that works with thirty regular contractors.

Ask each vendor how it counts occasional users and whether a minimum applies.

Getting your data out: praise, feedback and review history

The record of who did good work on which campaign is an agency's quiet asset. Praise, peer feedback and review notes help when you promote someone or write a reference. Ask each vendor how you can export them per person, and whether recognition posts stay in a readable archive after you leave. A reference letter written two years later depends on it.

Check the integrations that feed the tool, too. Weekdone and Perdoo connect to Slack and Teams, Workleap lists a long set including Jira, Notion and Workday, and Kenjo bundles absence and time tracking.

A tool that ties into your project tracker lets feedback follow the work.

Independence from the vendor: bundles, parents and roadmaps

A product that is one module of a bigger suite follows the suite's priorities. Workleap is a combined platform in which Officevibe is now part of the Workleap brand, and Kenjo and HiBob are HR systems first. If the vendor decides to retire a module, your feedback history moves with it or disappears. Ask who owns the AI features and where data goes.

Workleap says its AI drafts reviews for managers who decide, and Treams says its AI prepares conversations without judging people. A clear statement beats a vague promise, especially when the notes include comments about colleagues' creative work.

Who it's for: pitches, projects and one-person HR

Match the tool to the agency's size and its habits. A studio of 40 with no HR person wants quick feedback, praise and a few goals, which favors Small Improvements, Weekdone or Bonusly. A network agency of 150 with a real HR function, 1:1s across account teams and a talent review can use a fuller product. Dutch agencies with 100 or more people and an HR office have Treams as a locally built option, ranked third here, with digital and creative agencies among its verticals.

Agencies below that size will find the lighter tools easier to run. Whatever you pick, keep the first contract to one year, because an agency's headcount can change quickly after a lost or won account.

In every case, pick two finalists and run a short pilot before signing a year-long term.

Compared at a glance

#ProductBest forPricingFree optionHQ
1Small ImprovementsStudios of 20 to 750 wanting a fast startPer user / monthFree trialGermany
2WorkleapAgencies wanting feedback habits in chatYearly plan + per managerNoneCanada
3TreamsDutch agencies with an HR teamPer user / monthNoneNetherlands
4PerformYardAgencies of 50 to 500 with an HR leadPer user / monthNoneUnited States
515FiveMid-sized agencies training new leadsPer user / monthNoneUnited States
6WeekdoneSmall teams wanting a weekly ritualPer user / monthFree planEstonia
7PerdooAgencies setting company-wide goalsPer user / monthFree planGermany
8PrimalogikAgencies needing 360s and a first cycleQuote onlyFree trialCanada
9BonuslyAgencies fighting silence and churnPer user / monthFree trialUnited States
10KenjoAgencies of 20 to 80 without an HR systemPer employee / monthFree trialGermany
11HiBob (Bob)Growing agencies wanting HR records and reviewsQuote onlyNoneUnited Kingdom

The 11 tools, reviewed

How this list is ordered: by our editorial assessment of fit for organizations of 50 to 1,000 people. Vendors can pay for more visibility; how that works is explained in our disclosure, linked above every ranking. No commission is earned on clicks or purchases, and we do not work as an affiliate.

  1. 1

    #1 Small Improvements

    Review cycles with published prices and a trial

    Published pricesOptional calibrationBerlin vendor

    Why #1: First because it prints three prices, offers a 30-day trial and treats 360 feedback and optional calibration as a normal part of a light review cycle.

    Best for
    Studios of 20 to 750 wanting a fast start
    Pricing
    Per user / month
    Free option
    Free trial
    Headquarters
    Germany
    Key features
    Review templates, 360 feedback, Optional calibration, Objectives, 1:1 meetings
    Falls short
    There is no talent review, succession or compensation module, and analytics are adequate rather than deep.
    Wrong for
    Studios under 20 people and agencies that want a recognition feed with points.
    Full assessment of Small Improvements

    Small Improvements is a Berlin company that aims at teams of 50 to 750 and prints its prices, which suits an agency owner who wants a total before a sales call. Cycles launch from included templates, 360 feedback gathers input from colleagues from peers, and calibration can stay switched off until you want to compare teams.

    Objectives, praise and pulse surveys live under one login, so a manager does not juggle products. Its plain approach is easy to explain to a works council or a skeptical partner, which helps agencies in Germany and the Netherlands.

    It comes first for low risk and speed.

    Where it falls short

    There is no talent review, succession or compensation module, and analytics are adequate rather than deep. The 20-user minimum rules out the smallest studios, and the cheapest tier omits review controls an HR lead may want.

    Its pages name no agency customers or marketing focus.

    Wrong for

    Studios under 20 people and agencies that want a recognition feed with points. Bonusly or Weekdone fit those cases better.

    Full Small Improvements profile · Small Improvements alternatives · Visit website

  2. 2

    #2 Workleap

    HR platform with an AI agent, built on Officevibe

    Slack and TeamsRecognitionAI drafts

    Why #2: Second because it joins reviews, 1:1s, goals and pulse surveys with a recognition feature and Slack or Teams nudges, at a published yearly plan price.

    Best for
    Agencies wanting feedback habits in chat
    Pricing
    Yearly plan + per manager
    Free option
    None
    Headquarters
    Canada
    Key features
    Performance reviews, 360 feedback, 9-box grid, Calibration, 1:1 meetings
    Falls short
    There is no free plan or trial, plans are billed annually and the page says to book a demo.
    Wrong for
    Studios under about 20 people that want to pay per user.
    Full assessment of Workleap

    Workleap is the platform that Officevibe now sits inside, per its own page. It covers reviews with 360 feedback, a 9-box grid, calibration and upward reviews, plus pulse and custom surveys, anonymous feedback, 1:1 meetings, goals, analytics and a recognition feature called Good Vibes.

    Its AI drafts reviews for managers, who make the decision. Integrations include Slack, Teams, Outlook, Notion, Jira, Workday and BambooHR, and the page says that more than 100 vendors are supported, natively or through MCP.

    Professional services and technology appear among its industries.

    Where it falls short

    There is no free plan or trial, plans are billed annually and the page says to book a demo. The $4,999 yearly floor is steep for a studio of 15 people, and the manager fee grows with every team lead.

    Succession and career features are not named on the performance page, and integration logos are not clearly separated from customer logos.

    Wrong for

    Studios under about 20 people that want to pay per user. Small Improvements or Kenjo publish per-seat tiers.

    Full Workleap profile · Visit website

  3. 3

    #3 Treams

    Weekly 1:1s, goals and feedback for managers

    Netherlands1:1s and goalsISO 27001

    Why #3: Third because it fits Dutch digital and creative agencies with 100 or more people and an HR office, but has no recognition feed and no free tier.

    Best for
    Dutch agencies with an HR team
    Pricing
    Per user / month
    Free option
    None
    Headquarters
    Netherlands
    Key features
    1:1s and feedback, Goals and OKRs, Pulse surveys and eNPS, Growth paths, Skills matrix
    Falls short
    It has no recognition or praise feed, no free plan and no self-serve trial.
    Wrong for
    Agencies outside the Netherlands, studios of 20 to 60 people and teams that want peer praise first.
    Full assessment of Treams

    Treams is performance management software from Eindhoven for Dutch organizations with roughly 100 or more employees and an HR function, and digital and creative agencies are among the verticals it serves. A creative director or account lead gets a weekly rhythm of 1:1s, feedback and goals, with the 1:1 cadence set once and planned in both calendars.

    Pulse surveys and eNPS show mood by team, which matters when people leave for the next studio. Growth paths and a skills matrix give ambitious designers a visible route.

    AI prepares the conversation and never judges the person. It connects to AFAS, Visma, Nmbrs, Loket, Teams and Slack, holds ISO 27001, and publishes €6.50 and €9 per user per month.

    Where it falls short

    It has no recognition or praise feed, no free plan and no self-serve trial. A studio under 100 people or without an HR function is outside its stated range.

    Local connectors are strongest in the Dutch payroll market.

    Wrong for

    Agencies outside the Netherlands, studios of 20 to 60 people and teams that want peer praise first. Small Improvements, Weekdone or Bonusly fit those.

    Full Treams profile · Visit website

  4. 4

    #4 PerformYard

    Configurable reviews and goals with AI

    Marketing namedPublished rangeAI review builder

    Why #4: Fourth because it lists marketing among its industries and publishes a per-seat range, but arrives with more review structure than a small studio needs.

    Best for
    Agencies of 50 to 500 with an HR lead
    Pricing
    Per user / month
    Free option
    None
    Headquarters
    United States
    Key features
    Performance reviews, 1:1 meetings, Goals, 360 feedback, Pulse surveys
    Falls short
    Prices appear as a range, with no annual total shown, and there is no free plan or trial.
    Wrong for
    Studios that want recognition and weekly habits more than review cycles.
    Full assessment of PerformYard

    PerformYard is a US platform based in Arlington, Virginia, whose industry list names marketing beside consulting, software and accounting. It runs reviews, goals, 1:1s, engagement surveys and continuous feedback, with a talent suite adding competencies, career pathing and compensation.

    An AI assistant creates review forms and goals from a conversation, and a quality coach flags potential bias before submission. Integrations include Slack, Google, Microsoft 365, Okta, Rippling and Gusto, so a small studio can plug it into the tools it already pays for.

    The page says it serves companies of about 10 to over 1,000 staff.

    Where it falls short

    Prices appear as a range, with no annual total shown, and there is no free plan or trial. No dedicated learning module appeared on the pages we opened.

    The configurability that helps larger agencies can feel like work for a studio with no HR person.

    Wrong for

    Studios that want recognition and weekly habits more than review cycles. Bonusly or Weekdone are lighter and cheaper to run for a team that has no HR person.

    Full PerformYard profile · PerformYard alternatives · Visit website

  5. 5

    #5 15Five

    Reviews, check-ins and manager coaching

    Manager coachingCheck-insIntegrations

    Why #5: Fifth because it combines reviews, check-ins and manager coaching with a wide integration list, but add-ons are unpriced and agencies are not a named segment.

    Best for
    Mid-sized agencies training new leads
    Pricing
    Per user / month
    Free option
    None
    Headquarters
    United States
    Key features
    Performance reviews, 1-on-1s, Check-ins, OKRs, Engagement surveys
    Falls short
    No free plan or trial is stated, and the compensation and AI add-ons carry no published price.
    Wrong for
    Studios of fewer than 30 people and anyone who wants a simple recognition tool.
    Full assessment of 15Five

    15Five is an AI-assisted platform for mid-market and enterprise organizations that joins weekly check-ins, reviews, engagement surveys, OKRs and manager coaching. The Total Platform price includes manager training microlearnings, handy for an agency that promotes its best designers or strategists into lead roles with little training.

    A dedicated Teams integration powers High Fives praise, and the page lists links to Slack, Google Calendar, Zoom, Asana, Notion and Salesforce. It cites over 3,000 customer companies.

    Where it falls short

    No free plan or trial is stated, and the compensation and AI add-ons carry no published price. Headquarters is not stated on the pages we opened.

    Business services, software and finance are its named segments, so there is no direct agency evidence.

    Wrong for

    Studios of fewer than 30 people and anyone who wants a simple recognition tool. Bonusly and Small Improvements are cheaper starts.

    Full 15Five profile · 15Five alternatives · Visit website

  6. 6

    #6 Weekdone

    Weekly progress reports with OKRs

    Weekly reportsFree tierEstonian vendor

    Why #6: Sixth because it makes a weekly update the center of the product and pairs it with OKRs and a free tier, but its price list is hidden behind a selector.

    Best for
    Small teams wanting a weekly ritual
    Pricing
    Per user / month
    Free option
    Free plan
    Headquarters
    Estonia
    Key features
    OKR management, Weekly progress reports, Project tracking, Performance management, Developer API
    Falls short
    The page does not name Slack, Teams or Jira without another click, and the language selector offers English only.
    Wrong for
    Agencies that want formal reviews, 360 feedback or a recognition feed.
    Full assessment of Weekdone

    Weekdone is an Estonian product for managers who want a weekly update ritual before they want OKRs. Each person writes a short progress note, the manager reads a summary, and objectives sit beside the notes.

    The vendor says its OKR coaches offer team training, consultations and quarterly reviews at no extra cost, which helps an agency that has never run goals. A free plan for three users makes a pilot easy.

    Where it falls short

    The page does not name Slack, Teams or Jira without another click, and the language selector offers English only. Per-user prices sit behind a headcount selector, so comparing it with published lists takes extra work.

    It is lighter on review cycles and calibration than the tools above.

    Wrong for

    Agencies that want formal reviews, 360 feedback or a recognition feed. Small Improvements or Workleap cover that, and both are quicker to launch.

    Full Weekdone profile · Visit website

  7. 7

    #7 Perdoo

    OKRs, KPIs and a strategy map

    EU-basedStrategy mapFree tier

    Why #7: Seventh because it handles agency growth goals well, with a free plan and published pricing, but it covers OKRs only and no reviews.

    Best for
    Agencies setting company-wide goals
    Pricing
    Per user / month
    Free option
    Free plan
    Headquarters
    Germany
    Key features
    OKRs and KPIs, Strategy map, Check-ins and 1-on-1s, Projects and tasks, AI assistant
    Falls short
    Perdoo is a goals product.
    Wrong for
    Agencies looking for reviews, feedback or recognition.
    Full assessment of Perdoo

    Perdoo is a Hamburg company that suits an agency owner who wants the whole studio to see the same few goals: revenue, retention, a new service line. The strategy map ties an ultimate goal to pillars, objectives, KPIs and key results, check-ins and 1-on-1s are included, and customer data is stored in Frankfurt.

    Slack, Teams, Jira, Salesforce, HubSpot and Power BI are among its integrations. A free plan covers a pilot team, which suits a studio testing goals for the first time.

    Where it falls short

    Perdoo is a goals product. Its pages describe OKRs, KPIs, projects, tasks and meetings, not performance reviews or pay, so a second system is needed for ratings.

    Some sub-processors sit outside the EU under standard contractual clauses, and the free plan stops at five users.

    Wrong for

    Agencies looking for reviews, feedback or recognition. Small Improvements or Treams handle those, and Perdoo can sit beside them.

    Full Perdoo profile · Visit website

  8. 8

    #8 Primalogik

    360 feedback and reviews with onboarding included

    360 feedbackOnboarding includedTrial

    Why #8: Eighth because it bundles 360 feedback, reviews and goals with free onboarding and a trial, but prices are hidden and bundles start at 25 users.

    Best for
    Agencies needing 360s and a first cycle
    Pricing
    Quote only
    Free option
    Free trial
    Headquarters
    Canada
    Key features
    360 degree feedback, Performance reviews, Goals and OKRs, Real-time feedback, Employee surveys
    Falls short
    No prices are published, and each bundle has a 25-user minimum.
    Wrong for
    Teams that want published prices, a named security standard or a recognition feed.
    Full assessment of Primalogik

    Primalogik is a continuous performance platform with 360 degree feedback, reviews, goals, surveys and an employee journal, which gives managers a place to keep notes about a person across projects. Setup, training and onboarding are included without a setup fee, and a 30-day free trial opens every module to up to ten users.

    Annual plans bill ten months for twelve. Integrations named are Google, Microsoft, Slack, BambooHR and Okta.

    It targets startups and mid-sized companies and consultants.

    Where it falls short

    No prices are published, and each bundle has a 25-user minimum. Pages name no security certification, only a privacy policy and terms, and say nothing about succession.

    We could not confirm the current headquarters, only that it started in Montreal in 2012.

    Wrong for

    Teams that want published prices, a named security standard or a recognition feed. Small Improvements and Bonusly are clearer on those.

    Full Primalogik profile · Visit website

  9. 9

    #9 Bonusly

    Peer recognition with points in Slack and Teams

    Slack and TeamsPublished pricesPoints rewards

    Why #9: Ninth because it makes peer recognition easy in Slack or Teams from $3 per user, but it has no review module and the quote-only tier hides key features.

    Best for
    Agencies fighting silence and churn
    Pricing
    Per user / month
    Free option
    Free trial
    Headquarters
    United States
    Key features
    Peer recognition with points, Slack and Teams integration, Mobile apps, Automated milestones, HRIS integrations
    Falls short
    Nominations, incentives, spot bonuses and single sign-on only arrive with the quoted Organization plan.
    Wrong for
    Agencies that need ratings, goals or 360 feedback, and teams with no work chat app.
    Full assessment of Bonusly

    Bonusly is where an agency starts when the complaint is that good work goes unnoticed. People give each other points in Slack or Teams, rewards can be redeemed, and milestones such as work anniversaries post automatically.

    The plan page lists what each tier holds and what it costs, which is rare. Team covers recognition, milestones and HRIS provisioning, while Organization adds nominations, spot bonuses, SAML and analytics.

    It needs almost no setup, and an office manager can run it alone. Nothing in it replaces a conversation about growth, which is why it works best beside a review tool.

    Where it falls short

    Nominations, incentives, spot bonuses and single sign-on only arrive with the quoted Organization plan. The pricing page is inconsistent about the Bizy AI add-on, which is listed both as included and as an extra $2 per user.

    It has no reviews, goals or 1:1s.

    Wrong for

    Agencies that need ratings, goals or 360 feedback, and teams with no work chat app. Pair it with Small Improvements or choose Workleap.

    Full Bonusly profile · Visit website

  10. 10

    #10 Kenjo

    HR system with reviews and 360 cycles

    Berlin vendorHR systemPublished tiers

    Why #10: Tenth because it offers reviews and 360 cycles inside a low-priced HR system, but the review features are lighter than the specialists above.

    Best for
    Agencies of 20 to 80 without an HR system
    Pricing
    Per employee / month
    Free option
    Free trial
    Headquarters
    Germany
    Key features
    Performance reviews, 360 feedback, Goals and OKRs, Review templates, Absence management
    Falls short
    Goals and templates start at Growth, and the review dashboard is marked as coming soon and sits on Connect.
    Wrong for
    Agencies with a working HR system who want deeper reviews, and anyone wanting recognition.
    Full assessment of Kenjo

    Kenjo is a Berlin HR system whose pricing page lists performance reviews and 360 cycles in every tier, with goals, OKRs and review templates from Growth. For a small agency without an HR system, the published €6 and €10 prices and a 14-day trial make one login for absence, time and reviews a tidy answer.

    Pulse surveys and employee files sit in the same place, which keeps a small team from paying for three logins. The price is the argument, not the depth.

    A 30-person studio can run absence, time and its first review cycle in one place, and add a second tool only when the process outgrows it.

    Where it falls short

    Goals and templates start at Growth, and the review dashboard is marked as coming soon and sits on Connect. Calibration and talent review are not listed on the pages we read.

    Larger agencies will outgrow its reporting, and nothing on the site points to agencies.

    Wrong for

    Agencies with a working HR system who want deeper reviews, and anyone wanting recognition. Small Improvements fits the first need and Bonusly the second.

    Full Kenjo profile · Visit website

  11. 11

    #11 HiBob (Bob)

    People platform with talent modules

    HR platformQuote onlyMid-market

    Why #11: Eleventh because it merges core HR records with goals, reviews and learning for mid-sized firms, but prices are by quote and review features are lighter.

    Best for
    Growing agencies wanting HR records and reviews
    Pricing
    Quote only
    Free option
    None
    Headquarters
    United Kingdom
    Key features
    Performance reviews, Goals, Feedback and recognition, Learning paths, Compensation
    Falls short
    No price appears on the pages opened, and no free plan or trial is stated.
    Wrong for
    Small studios that want a quick, cheap feedback tool, and agencies already happy with their HR system.
    Full assessment of HiBob (Bob)

    HiBob is a people platform that combines core HR records with goals, performance reviews, feedback and recognition, learning paths and compensation. Its size menu names startups, small and mid-sized companies and enterprises.

    Its performance page lists goals, progress tracking and review running. An AFAS link, built and run by BrynQ, passes employee data and payroll information in both directions.

    Agencies that have outgrown spreadsheets and want records and reviews together will recognize the shape.

    Where it falls short

    No price appears on the pages opened, and no free plan or trial is stated. The AFAS page does not mention performance modules.

    1:1s are described as a recommended practice rather than a module. Headquarters is not stated there.

    Wrong for

    Small studios that want a quick, cheap feedback tool, and agencies already happy with their HR system. Small Improvements is lighter.

    Full HiBob (Bob) profile · HiBob (Bob) alternatives · Visit website

What the data says about this market

We opened each vendor's pages and looked for marketing or agency language. PerformYard lists marketing among its industries, and Treams names digital and creative agencies as one of its verticals. Workleap lists professional services and technology.

None of the other nine names agencies, so most of the fit in this ranking is inferred from features and from how small teams work, not from agency customers. That is a limit worth knowing before you read the order as a verdict. What the pages do describe is recognition, chat prompts and quick feedback.

Bonusly, Workleap and Weekdone put those first. Cycle-heavy suites barely mention them, which tells you what each vendor expects a customer to be like.

Price information is better than in most HR categories. Seven of the eleven tools print a per-seat number: Small Improvements, PerformYard, 15Five, Kenjo, Treams, Bonusly and Perdoo. Perdoo publishes a Premium price and a free tier, Weekdone a free plan for up to three users, and Bonusly a Team tier from $3.

Workleap publishes a yearly plan price plus a per-manager fee, and Primalogik and HiBob ask for a quote. At 30 people, Small Improvements' Launch tier comes to $1,080 a year before add-ons, and most of the others cost two to four times that.

The split that matters is between tools that treat feedback as a habit and tools that treat it as a cycle. Bonusly and Weekdone work weekly. Small Improvements and PerformYard center on review cycles with optional calibration.

Treams and 15Five sit in between with frequent 1:1s and goals. Agencies that suffer from turnover often benefit from the habit side first and add a formal cycle once an HR person exists. That order also keeps the tool cheap while the team is small.

How to choose

1. Decide what you want to change in the next six months

Write down the one problem you want the tool to ease. It might be that nobody gives feedback after a pitch, that your best designers leave without warning, or that promotion decisions look arbitrary. Pick the product whose first screen addresses that problem.

A recognition-first tool, such as Bonusly, answers silence. A 1:1 and goals tool answers drift.

A review tool answers fairness. Showing each vendor your one-sentence problem makes the demo shorter and the comparison clearer, and it protects you from buying a cycle-heavy system for a culture problem.

2. Run a four-week pilot with one account team and one creative team

Choose two groups with different habits, an account team that talks to clients all day and a creative team that works in bursts. Ask each person to give two pieces of feedback and have one 1:1 in the tool. Afterward ask three questions: did it arrive where people already work, did it feel like extra work, and would the managers keep going without a reminder?

The answers show more than a feature list. Make the office manager time how long it takes to set up the second cycle.

If it takes a day, the tool will not last.

3. Test the exit and the freelancer rules before you sign

Ask each shortlisted vendor to quote for your core staff and for the freelancers you want in the tool, and to say what happens to data after cancellation. Request an export of praise, feedback and review notes per person. Read the minimum-user clause and the term: a 20-user floor or a $6,000 floor can matter to a studio of 25.

Red flags are a price page that contradicts itself, a bundle you cannot unbundle, and a vendor that will not describe how it stores comments about colleagues. Keep the contract term short for the first year.

Put every promise about price, minimums and data return into the order form, so it survives a change of sales contact.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best performance management software for marketing and creative agencies in 2026?

Treams ranks third here, behind Small Improvements and Workleap. Small Improvements is the pick for a small studio that wants published prices and a trial, and Workleap for agencies that want feedback and 1:1s with a Slack or Teams habit. Dutch agencies with 100 or more people and an HR function should look at Treams, and PerformYard lists marketing among its industries.

Which tool is simplest for a studio of 20 to 40 people?

Small Improvements, if you meet its 20-user minimum. It lists $3, $6 and $9 plans, a 30-day free trial and optional calibration. Bonusly starts at $3 per user for recognition and Weekdone has a free plan for up to three users. Perdoo's free plan stops at five users and covers OKRs, not reviews.

How do I keep feedback flowing after pitches and campaigns?

Use a tool that prompts people in the chat app after the event. Bonusly runs through Slack or Teams, Weekdone asks for weekly updates, and Workleap sends nudges through its agent. Treams and 15Five schedule 1:1s and feedback in the manager's week. Pick one habit, such as a three-line note after each pitch, and measure it for a month.

If the habit does not stick in four weeks, the tool is the wrong shape for your team, however good its demo looked.

Does Treams work for an agency?

It does for Dutch digital and creative agencies with 100 or more employees and an HR function. Treams lists digital and creative agencies among its verticals and builds weekly 1:1s, feedback and goals around the manager's week. It is not meant for studios below that size or without an HR person, and it has no recognition feed, which is why Small Improvements and Workleap rank above it.

Can freelancers be included?

Usually only as paid seats, so ask first. None of the vendors we read describes a free freelancer role, and Small Improvements applies a 20-user minimum. A common workaround is to give freelancers a lightweight feedback request by link, where the product allows it. Count regular contractors in your quote, since a studio that leans on freelancers can double its seat count.

Ask the vendor to put the answer in the order form, not only in an email.

What does recognition software add?

It makes praise visible, which matters when work is late-night and project-based. Bonusly offers peer recognition with points and works inside Slack and Teams. Workleap includes a recognition feature called Good Vibes. Recognition does not replace a review, and Bonusly has no review module, so pair it with one if you need ratings.

Is OKR software useful for an agency?

Only for the agency's own growth targets, not client projects. Perdoo is an OKR product and does not cover reviews, and Weekdone pairs OKRs with weekly updates. An agency that wants revenue, hiring and retention goals visible can use them. Client delivery belongs in a project tool.

Treams and 15Five link goals to 1:1s, which is closer to what a creative director needs.

How much does it cost for 40 people?

From about $1,400 to more than $7,000 a year on published list prices. Small Improvements Launch at $3 comes to $1,440. Kenjo at €6 comes to €2,880, Treams Flow at €6.50 to €3,120, and PerformYard's $5 to $15 range to $2,400 to $7,200. 15Five Perform at $11 is $5,280.

Quote-only vendors need a call, and add-ons raise totals.

Do these tools help with high turnover?

They surface the warning signs but cannot fix pay or workload. Pulse surveys, such as those in Workleap, Small Improvements and Treams, show mood by team. Regular 1:1s catch frustration earlier than exit interviews. Primalogik adds an employee journal.

None of the vendors we read publishes a turnover result we could verify independently, so treat their claims as unproven.

Which tools need an HR system?

Kenjo and HiBob are HR systems first and add reviews as modules. If you have no HR system, one of them can serve both purposes for a small team. If you already run payroll and HR, PerformYard and 15Five connect to existing systems, and Treams links to AFAS, Visma, Nmbrs and Loket. Check whether the employee list syncs both ways, and who fixes it when a new hire appears in one system but not the other.

Should an agency use AI features for reviews?

Use them to draft, not to decide. Workleap says its AI drafts reviews for managers who make the final decision, PerformYard has a coach that flags possible bias, and Treams' AI prepares conversations without judging people. Comments about colleagues' creative work are sensitive, so ask where the data goes and whether it trains the model. Ask too whether an employee can see what the AI wrote before a manager sends it.